Who Represents Islam?   1 comment

Qutb

After last night’s vicious attack in London, British media outlets, as usual, started to seek statements of condemnation from Muslim figures. This morning I had my breakfast while watching a senior figure in the Ahmedi sect defending Islam and talking about how the terrorists do not represent it. For me this did not lack black comedy since Ahmedis are not even considered Muslims by the rest of the Islamic world. They are considered to be “infidels” and not just heretics or apostates. Shortly later, another Muslim cleric releases a statement on behalf of the British Muslim council citing weak Hadiths (a Hadith is a saying of Muhammed preserved through tradition – a weak Hadith means that its origin is dubious and hence it has no authority) and abrogated verses (verses about how Muslims should treat others peacefully, these verses were abrogaded by the later verses that exhort Muslims to seek militant jihad and force Christians and Jews to pay taxes called Jiziah if they want to keep their heads and bodies intact – check the final Surah of al-Tawbah).

I am not intending to offer a comprehensive explanation for the dynamics of power and authority in Islam  since there isn’t, practically, a single one. Yet, one important question should be asked by every western viewer who found themselves snowed under with forceful statements about how Jihadists do not represent Islam: why?

Why cannot be the “extremists” the ones who represent Islam while the others are the “heretic”?

Is it because the version of the militant Islamists is not favourable? well, if you don’t like something it doesn’t mean it is not true!

Representing Islam should not be left to our presumptuous, wishful thinking or cherry picking. It is a serious scholarly problem that should be subject to honest historical and scientific criticism, then the results should be conveyed to the public. Islam, like Christianity and Judaism, must be subjected to the different forms of criticism and Muslims should be the first to do that with honesty in order to deliver an honest statement about the historical Islam or what could represent Islam. Otherwise, the problem will remain and terrorism will continue since its root ideology is dismissed a priori.

In the picture of this post, you will see an Egyptian Muslim scholar whose writings remain to be one of the most influential writings since the time of the main 4 scholars of Islam.  His name is Sayed Qutb. In the Shades of Quran was his comprehensive commentary on Quran. Qutb was the ideologist of the Muslim Brotherhood, the mother of the most prominent Jihadist movements including Qaeda and ISIS.

Since the foundation of this movement in 1928, the United Kingdom has provided its support and protection of the Muslim Brotherhood who, in return, helped the British government whenever the Egyptian king (and later presidents like Nasser) works against its interests. The Muslim Brotherhood has its international headquarters in London and from here it operates internationally to poison generations of Muslims with its comprehensive literature. Qutbists (those who are totally loyal to Qutb’s ideology) like Abdulmoneim abulFuttuh are received in London’s Chatham House regularly. Why do people dismiss Jihadists while they protect their ideologists and propagandists in the political sphere?

In the next post I will go with you briefly through Qutb’s commentary on the most important Surah (al-Tawbah) which identifies the relations between Muslims and non-Muslims. We will see how strong and comprehensive his treatment of the sources is.

Advertisements

Posted June 4, 2017 by Mina Monier in Uncategorized

One response to “Who Represents Islam?

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Dear Minas,

    It seems that Muslim scholars are just as confused as Christian scholars.

    Geoff

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: